The pursuit of happiness, the nature of cinematic artifice, and female emancipation were just a few of the themes that ran through my viewings at this year's Cinema Reborn festival of restored classic films.
Once again, Cinema Reborn showed itself to be a world-class event and a highlight of the serious cinephile's year - every bit worthy of being counted among the world's great festivals alongside the venerable Festival Il Cinema Ritrovato at Bologna and UCLA's Festival of Preservation.
This year, there were twenty three programs on show, from all over the world (including right here in Australia, with a rare screening of three local social realist shorts). Prioritising pre-1960 films, I was able to see six. It was lovely to catch up with festival director Geoffrey Gardner, and to grab a coffee with Queensland-based silent film aficionado Joel Archer to discuss our mutual adoration of Smouldering Fires (1925), Mary Pickford, and everything in between!
Port of Shadows (1938)
Much like Josef von Sternberg’s The Docks of New York (1928), we find ourselves in a world that exists on the edges - between ocean and land, between polite society and the criminal underworld, where people drift up against one another like so much flotsam and jetsam and experience the briefest happiness, only to be pulled on their way by the tide.
Jean Gabin plays a sardonic soldier - a deserter, as it transpires - who finds refuge at the Havana, a seedy dockside bar in the French port city of Le Havre. Expecting no more friends than the stray dog who takes a shine to him, he forms a kind of allegiance with the misfits within, including a perpetual drunk (Raymond Aimos) and a poetic, suicidal artist (Robert Le Vigan).
He soon becomes involved with the beautiful but troubled Nelly (Michéle Morgan), who has run away from her guardian Zabel (Michel Simon), for reasons that initially seem mysterious. She is also dealing with the disappearance of her gangster boyfriend Maurice, possibly a victim of the rather sissified petty crook Lucien (Pierre Brasseur), with whom Jean also tangles. When the painter makes good his threat of self-annihilation, he throws Jean a lifeline: clothes, a passport, a new identity, and a means of escape.
Will he grasp the opportunity with both hands and abandon Nelly to her fate, or does a happy ending await the lovers? Well, this is a Jean Gabin film from the 1930s, so I will say no more. Shown in a gorgeous new 4K restoration, this is an atmospheric and melancholy delight, whose message is that any happiness that washes upon our shore is worth embracing, for it will surely be gone with the next tide.
White Nights (1957)
Marcello Mastroianni is Mario, a young flâneur in the Italian port city of Livorno, who notices a young woman, Natalia (Maria Schell) crying on a bridge. After saving her from some ruffians, he becomes bewitched by her and her story.
Unable to free herself from her guardian’s apron strings (quite literally - her repressive grandmother pins the girl’s skirt to her own), the naive Natalia had fallen in love with a handsome lodger (Jean Marais, playing at an appropriately godlike remove). After a brief, furtive romance, the lodger departed, promising to return to her after a year. The year has almost passed and there has been no sign of him.
Given the likelihood that she has been led up the garden path by this would-be paramour, and realising his own growing feelings for Natalia, Mario sets about giving her the time of her life in an attempt to bring her back to earth, forget this intransigent lover, and win her for himself.
Fairytale films are notoriously hard to pull off. For every Seventh Heaven (1927) or Sunrise: A Song of Two Humans (1927), there’s an Angels Over Broadway (1940) - a fey misfire which, as one review of that film put it at the time, fails to ‘carefully etch human beings’. This last quality was at the heart of why White Nights didn't quite work for me.
The man difficulty I had was with Maria Schell’s character - an exemplar of the archetype which, some fifty years later, would be branded the ‘Manic Pixie Dream Girl.’ She pouts, flirts, beams, blinks, shies away like a startled faun and just generally behaves like no human being ever acted, which we are intended to find winsome, but instead makes you want to give her a firm shake and beg her to get a grip on herself.
This is a shame, because there is so much to like about this film - its sense of heightened reality (an evocatively artificial Livorno was recreated on a soundstage), and some charming passages, such as the scene where the couple, with echoes of the similar sequence in Sunrise: A Song of Two Humans, crash a fashionable dance party in their own inimitable style. Yet for me, Natalia's naivete and her inability to divest herself of her fantasies remained an impenetrable barrier to the suspension of disbelief, so crucial to the success of a film such as this. No doubt I am in the minority.
The Heiress (1949)
At the end of White Nights I thought to myself “Well - what now? What happens when the fairytale ends and real life begins?” You could hardly find a better or more satisfying answer than in the emotionally complex The Heiress (1949), which just goes to show how differently two superficially similar stories can be received, depending on how they are told.
It’s New York in the nineteenth century, and Catherine Hough (Olivia de Havilland) is a mousy old maid with slim prospects aside from a large inheritance left by her late mother. This will be increased even further after the passing of her domineering father (Ralph Richardson). When handsome young Morrison Townsend (Montgomery Clift) comes calling, she is transformed by a level of attention never afforded her by her family.
Scorned by her wary father, who suspects that Townsend is after nothing more than her inheritance, but encouraged by her romantic, feather-headed Aunt Lavinia (the always delightful Miriam Hopkins, bringing some light relief to proceedings), the pair make preparations to elope - but Catherine’s dream of her future comes crashing down in dramatic fashion. Like Natalia of White Nights, will she weep on a bridge as she awaits the return of her white knight - or will she accept reality and use it to forge a newly powerful sense of her own self worth?
This is one of those films that finds a director in perfect concert with their lead performer. Wyler’s expert hand unwinds the story at just the right pace. Olivia de Havilland is one of those performers (Barbara Stanwyck was another) who can ‘play’ plain, or beautiful, naive or knowing, powerless or powerful, sometimes making the transition almost imperceptibly within the course of a single scene, her voice deepening and her face hardening. By the end of the film, the character is almost unrecognisable from when we first met her. It’s a powerhouse performance, for which de Havilland rightly won the Academy Award.
Wyler was reportedly encouraged to make Montgomery Clift’s character more sympathetic. In lesser hands, this ambiguity might have muddied the waters and made Townsend seem wishy-washy. Instead, it adds a welcome complexity to their relationship: is Townsend simply after Catherine’s money, or does he find himself genuinely falling in love with her? The fact that the answer is never made explicit makes the denouement all the more powerful: neither really matters as much as Catherine’s own emancipation. I was almost ready to cheer on her behalf when the film reached its conclusion: no conventional fairytale ending, but something much deeper and more satisfying.
Only Angels Have Wings (1939)
As with Port of Shadows, our story unfolds in one of humanity’s waystations, a seaport at the fictional South American outpost of Barranca. The rough-and-tumble life of the pilots who operate a rag-tag airline out of a local tavern is interrupted by the arrival of Bonnie (Jean Arthur), a visiting showgirl who flirts with a young pilot (Noah Beery Jr), only to witness his death in a landing accident.
Irresistibly drawn to their lifestyle - and especially to their hard-bitten leader Geoff (Cary Grant) - Bonnie decides to stick around, witnessing the pilots’ attempts to brave brutal weather and their own doubts and infirmities. The arrival of veteran flyer Bat MacPherson (Richard Barthelmess) and his new wife Judy (Rita Hayworth) throws a further spanner in the works, for Judy is an old paramour of Geoff’s, while MacPherson, shunned after he parachuted out of a doomed plane to let another pilot die, faces an uphill battle to regain the respect of his peers.
The cast is a strong and varied one. There’s the headliners, Cary Grant, in unusually brusque Clark Gable-esque mode, and Jean Arthur, as always inimitably Jean Arthur, which is more than enough; there’s reliably excellent supporting players (Thomas Mitchell, Allyn Joslyn), one returning veteran (Dick Barthelmess, who left retirement for what proved a perfect comeback role) and a notable new talent (Rita Hayworth, effective in her small part). Yet it’s a difficult movie to summarise, or to put your finger on its appeal - long and somewhat episodic, yet it holds your attention from beginning to end.
As with Red Dust (1932), of which it is reminiscent, it is the strength of the characters and the sense of place that keeps us engaged. We feel as if we are crammed in with these people, sharing their privations, their dislocation and their outsized feelings. Much like Bonnie, we're strangely reluctant to leave them. This new 4K restoration looked and sounded stunning, particularly the thrilling sequences of aircraft swooping and dipping around the Andes.
Artists and Models (1955)
Rick (Dean Martin) is a struggling artist whose latest job comes unstuck courtesy of the latest obsession of his oddball pal Eugene (Jerry Lewis): a comic book about a comely superheroine named Bat Lady. In the cartoonish Technicolor world in which this film exists, who should they run into at their new apartment but Abigail (Dorothy Malone), the artist who created Bat Lady and her friend and secretary Bessie (Shirley MacLaine), the model for Bat Lady herself?
After Abigail quits authoring Bat Lady in protest of the excessive violence she has been asked to add to the storylines, Rick sees a job opportunity, as well as a chance for romance. Singing, dancing, gorgeous costuming and pratfalls ensue - and yes, so does a spy plot involving Eva Gabor because heck, why not? It’s anything goes in this kind of featherlight entertainment.
The choice of animation veteran Frank Tashlin to direct two of cinema’s prime cartoon characters is an inspired one, allowing us to suspend our disbelief just enough to accept that Lewis can be twisted like a pretzel on the massage table - and, for that matter, that Shirley MacLaine’s character is madly in love with Lewis.’
The view of Lewis’ character - that life is bearable so long as you are able to indulge in fantasy just for a little while - is not only the closest you’ll get to philosophy in a Jerry Lewis film, but a pretty good way of thinking of films of this kind in general. They’re colourful and amusing and have nothing whatsoever to do with the real world. And they’re all the better for it.
One Hour With You (1932)
Here’s a novel concept in Pre-Codes - a couple whose turn-on is radical monogamy! Maurice Chevalier is Dr André Bertier, and Jeanette MacDonald is his wife Colette, with whom he shares a double bed that this besotted couple clearly use enthusiastically and often.
Enter Mitzi (Genevieve Tobin), Colette’s coquettish school chum, who sets her sights on André and is determined to break down his romantic defenses. André resists her attention as far as he can … but “Oh, that Mitzi!” Meanwhile, Colette is not remotely tempted by her own would-be suitor, Adolph (Charlie Ruggles) - though she may eventually find him useful in the playful battle-of-the-sexes that ensues.
Chevalier and MacDonald strut and fret through their immaculate Paris Art Deco apartment, drop some laugh-out-loud one liners and occasionally lean through the fourth wall to address the audience. Though both Ernst Lubitsch and George Cukor worked on the film - who did what is up for debate - there’s a distinct Continental flavour to proceedings; the use of sprechgesang, which can easily feel awkward in an English language film, is charming, which is true of the entire film. What might have been tedious or awkward in lesser hands is completely beguiling.
If there’s a quibble to be had, it's that we’re openly invited to speculate that Chevalier’s halo has slipped, whereas MacDonald’s remains firmly intact. But, as the characters seem to be reminding us in their addresses to the audience: it’s all just good-natured fun anyway. And - well, what would you do if a sexy someone wanted to spend one hour with you?
An absolutely delightful end to the festival.
All in all, another very solid and enjoyable line-up. This year, I missed out on one film I had hoped to see (Luis Bunel’s El) but got along to another that I didn’t expect to (White Nights), so the ledgers were balanced pretty well. Although there was no silent film in the 2026 line-up, the pre-1960 offerings were diverse and immensely satisfying.
I’m told that attendances were well up this year, and it was gratifying to see near capacity audiences for White Nights and The Heiress. That the audience for the encore screening of One Hour With You was undeservedly small might have escaped your notice if you’d been outside listening to the laughter.
As we see at the end of The Crowd (1928) - another recent restoration which, we hope, might make it to next year’s festival - sometimes, in our times of struggle and adversity, the best we can do is sit in a darkened room, partake in the imagined lives of others, and abandon ourselves to the images on the screen.
Thanks to all who make Cinema Reborn possible, and as always, I’m looking forward to next year.